# The Bucker autonomy scale

Version 2026-11-14. This page and `GET /public/autonomy-scale` are generated from one source
(`domain/src/modules/autonomy/public-scale.ts`) and carry no organization data.

## Levels

| Level | Name | Read from | An agent may | A person still decides |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 0 | Observe | none | Nothing is recorded as acting: agents read and report, and no ladder row exists. | Every change, because no agent has proposed one. |
| 1 | Investigate | `RCA_ONLY` | Explain a cause. An agent held here (or demoted here) may still ask for a governed act, and every such request needs at least two approvers. | Every change, with two approvers for any request the agent makes. |
| 2 | Propose | `DRAFT_PR` | Ask for a governed act or open a draft change. The request waits for a person; the policy row decides how many approvers it needs, and the rung only ever raises that count. | Every request, and the merge of every change. |
| 3 | Attempt | `AUTO_ATTEMPT` | Attempt a change inside the envelope a person set, where the category allows one approver. The attempt is verified afterwards and a failed verification demotes the rung. | The envelope, the merge, and anything the category floors at ask. |
| 4 | Earned | `AUTO_ATTEMPT` with an earned grant | Attempt the same, and lower a configuration-class request from sensitive to elevated, but only in a category where measured evidence earned it: verified outcomes, a shadow trial, a person accepting with a step-up. A revert or a failed verification demotes it automatically. | Accepting the grant, every safety-class and lever act, and the merge. |

## Where an organization sits

An organization sits at the highest level any production ladder row of its own holds. Rows from a non-production environment class are not counted.
The organization’s level is returned by the `autonomy_profile_get` tool beside the per-category
evidence; raising a rung is a person’s act with a step-up and no level can be reached by an agent
alone.

## What never moves

- Merging stays a person’s act at every level.
- Human-only acts (identity, credentials, access, billing, deletion) stay a person’s at every level.
- No rung covers an act that widens reach, launches, ships, resumes, publishes, deletes or erases.
- A safety-class category never leaves shadow, and a rung earned in one environment class is never read in another.
- A demotion never needs a person: a revert or a failed verification drops the rung by itself.

The acts no rung can cover are read from the engine’s own table: verbs `widen`, `launch`, `ship`, `resume`, `publish`, `certify`, `verify`, `delete`, `merge`, `erase`, `purge`; objects `host`, `credential`.

## What this scale is not

A level describes what the organization has granted, not how safe the agent is. It is not a certification, and no level makes a measured failure rate zero (see the injection miss-rate register).
